Our third workshop, and the final one in this initial series, took place on 13 May. The format was a sort of ‘dragon’s den’ – network members were invited to pitch project ideas, and get feedback from our panel of fantastic colleagues: Rebecca Bailey (Historic Environment Scotland); Professor Sian Bayne (Director of Centre for Research in Digital Education, University of Edinburgh; Professor Chris Breward (Edinburgh College of Art) and Dr Emily Pringle (Head of Learning Practice and Research, Tate). Here they are, intently consulting their notes before the start of the panel discussion:
After the panel made introductions and outlined their digital cultural heritage backgrounds, a number of challenging questions were raised and debated, including:
- What are the challenges for cultural organisations in terms of digital co-production?
- What are some organisational priorities for developing digital strategies?
- ‘Harnessing’ is a problematic term in relation to the digital – it suggests digital drives itself, moves forward and is there to be captured. How should we be thinking about these issues?
- Institutional contexts of scale matter – how can larger and smaller organisations work together and learn from each other?
- What does it mean for digital content to be ‘evergreen’ – are there tensions here between ‘relevance’ to a wide audience and the archival value of older content?
Next, we heard four ‘pitches’ for research or impact project ideas at a variety of stages:
- Niki Vermeulen (Science, Technology and Innovation Studies) – Curious Edinburgh
- Jen Ross (Digital Education) and Glyn Davis (Edinburgh College of Art) – Open futures for cultural heritage collections
- Victoria Anker and James Loxley (Literatures, Languages and Cultures) – Interrupted Lives: Saving the Self in the British and Irish Civil Wars
- Kirsty Lingstadt (Historic Environment Scotland, with Rebecca standing in for her, as she was unable to join us), Claire Sowton (Digital Education) and Chris Speed (Design Informatics) – what could Canmore do?
Last but not least, Anne Sofie Laegran, Knowledge Exchange Manager from the College of Humanities and Social Sciences, talked to the group about developing partnerships and pathways to impact – with some extremely helpful ideas and suggestions for network members as we move forward.
We closed with a brief discussion about the future of the network… stay tuned for more on this!
Good to be at #dchrn again! So far, excellent lunch.
— Hannah Brown (@heritageNinja) May 13, 2016
Uniqueness of digital but sometimes there are things that aren't done brilliantly by digital. Think about the real… #DCHRN
— Hannah Brown (@heritageNinja) May 13, 2016
Should all content be 'evergreen'? Whats wrong with ephemeral content? Maybe not a cultural heritage way of thinking?! Is it healthy? #DCHRN
— Hannah Brown (@heritageNinja) May 13, 2016
satisfyingly difficult questions being raised at #dchrn for an ecofeminist on archiving – evergreen data; decaying data; harvesting data?
— Niamh Moore (@rawfeminism) May 13, 2016
Digitalisation can make widely available these background details. People can have access to much more #DCHRN
— Hannah Brown (@heritageNinja) May 13, 2016
the urge to own data by insitutions or the possibilities of created shared archives where data can be sustained and accessed? #dchrn
— Niamh Moore (@rawfeminism) May 13, 2016
challenges – funding requires data to be sustained beyond the project; but getting funding to create infrastructures is a challenge #dchrn
— Niamh Moore (@rawfeminism) May 13, 2016
Emily Pringle from Tate on the persistence of idea of website as broadcast #DCHRN
— Niamh Moore (@rawfeminism) May 13, 2016
Need for money, time and space in first pitch…sounds familiar… #DCHRN
— Hannah Brown (@heritageNinja) May 13, 2016
#DCHRN Listening to fascinating digital cultural heritage research pitches this afternoon @jar @warholmooc pic.twitter.com/JLbK7doxBg
— Claire Sowton (@_ClaireSowton) May 13, 2016
.@jar namechecking https://t.co/1bjyjfIO3H at the #DCHRN. Now desperately trying not to giggle at the images.
— Lorna M. Campbell (@LornaMCampbell) May 13, 2016
https://twitter.com/LornaMCampbell/status/731816905577771009
https://twitter.com/oldnorthroad/status/731150436800077825